UPDATE: Deferred sentence issued in fake nursing credentials case
August 31, 2026 | Courts|FeaturedNEWKIRK — Stacey Sue McDonald-Stigall, 54, Ponca City, appeared in Kay County District Court and entered no contest pleas to felony counts of second degree burglary, identity theft-unlawful use of personal identifying information and a misdemeanor count of fraudulently using licensed professional nurse title. With her attorney, Todd Burlie present and prosecutor Billie Chrz, Judge Lee Turner deferred sentencing for seven years and ordered her to obtain a mental health evaluation and complete 100 hours of community service.
UPDATE: Failure to appear warrant issued for woman accused of using fake nursing credentials
NEWKIRK — Officials report that Stacey Sue McDonald-Stigall, 53, Ponca City, failed to appear for a preliminary hearing this week in Kay County District Court. A warrant with bond endorsed at $25,000 is issued.
Court date set for woman accused of fraudulently using nursing credentials
NEWKIRK — An initial appearance is scheduled in Kay County District Court for Stacey Sue McDonald-Stigall, 50, Ponca City.
McDonald-Stigall is facing felony charges of second degree burglary, identity theft-unlawful use of personal identifying info and fraudulently using licensed professional nurse title.
Ponca City police report that Alicia Cummings, program director at Right Way Medical, reported that McDonald-Stigall may have provided the company false credentials.
McDonald-Stigal was working as a Licensed Practical Nurse.

Cummings reportedly told police that on April 5, she pulled McDonald-Stigall’s file and the file of Sandra Ailey and left them on her desk. The next day the files were gone.
Cummings told police that she checked with security and that video reportedly shows McDonald-Stigall entering the building, turned the off alarm, went into Cummings’ office and then leave holding files under her shirt.
She reportedly turned the alarm back on and left.
Police questioned Ailey who reportedly said she was worried that McDonald-Stigall would use her nursing license.
Officers reviewed the video and then tracked down McDonald-Stigall.
She reportedly told police that she went back to the business to get her files including her CPR certification card and shot record.
“I hid the papers under my shirt because I was afraid they wouldn’t let me take my continuing education papers,” she said.
She denied taking the other files.
On April 22, Cummings provided police with a copy of a license belonging to Stacy LaBlue that McDonald-Stigall had been using.
Police contacted LaBlue who stated she has never worked at Right Way Medical and does not know McDonald-Stigall.
On April 23, police contacted McDonald-Stigall and asked if she had a valid nursing license in Oklahoma.
She reportedly told police that she is a LPN in Kansas and has been signing LPN after her name.
Police report they checked the Kansas and Oklahoma Board of Nursing websites and reportedly found no license for her in either state.
On April 25 police met with Rod Cargill, executive director of Right Way Medical. Cargill reportedly told police that credentials provided by McDonald-Stigall when she was first hired belonged to Stacey Lynn Sheffield, who now works in Montana.
Police contacted Sheffield and she said there has been unusual activity with her DEA number and that she wanted to press charges.
McDonald-Stigall was arrested on May 26 and later released on $10,000 bond.





